Skip to content
digitalaudits.com.au

How Google decides what to show

By · 4 min read · Published · Updated

How Google decides what to show

A new website goes live on a Friday, and by the following month the phone has gone quiet. Nobody touched the old rankings on purpose. Somewhere in the launch, a box marked “discourage search engines from indexing this site” stayed ticked, and Google did exactly what it was told.

Most of what happens to a small business in Google comes down to moments like that. Owners hear that Google uses hundreds of secret signals and decide the whole thing is out of their hands, so they either ignore it or pay someone without knowing what they’re paying for.

Google’s process is less mysterious than it looks. Every page Google ranks has first been found and read, and knowing roughly how each step works tells you where your effort pays off.

Finding your pages

Google uses automated programs, called crawlers or Googlebot, that visit web pages and follow the links on them to find new ones. If Google can’t reach a page, it can’t show it, however good the page is.

The most common blocker is a file called robots.txt, a short set of instructions on your site that tells crawlers where they may go. A single wrong line can shut Google out of the whole site, and it happens most often straight after a new website launch. The next most common is a “noindex” setting left on from when the site was being built, which tells Google to leave the page out of its results.

Pages that nothing links to are hard to find too. A sitemap helps, because it gives Google a list of every page you want it to know about, but the best signal is a link from your homepage or main menu.

Understanding your pages

Once Google has read a page, it works out what the page is about and files it in its index, a vast catalogue of the pages it knows. The page title is the single biggest clue, followed by the main heading, known as the H1. Google also reads the words on the page, including how you describe your services and where you work, and the descriptions attached to images, called alt text, because it can’t fully see pictures.

Structured data helps it along. It’s a hidden format that spells out details like your business name, address, opening hours and reviews, so Google doesn’t have to guess them from the page.

Clear, specific wording makes the job easy. A page titled “Home” with a heading that says “Welcome!” gives Google almost nothing to go on, while a page titled “Emergency electrician in Newcastle” with a heading to match leaves no doubt.

Ranking your pages

When someone searches, Google picks the pages that best match what they want and puts them in order. It weighs hundreds of signals, but for a small business a handful do most of the work.

Relevance comes first: a page about exactly “hot water system repairs” beats a general services page for that search. For local searches, location matters a lot, which means being close to the person searching and saying clearly that you serve their area. Trust counts too, built from reviews and from other reputable sites that mention or link to you. Page experience rounds it out, meaning whether your site loads quickly on a phone and uses a secure HTTPS connection.

The map results and AI answers

For local searches, Google usually shows a map with three businesses before the normal results. Those come mostly from Google Business Profiles, the free listings businesses manage themselves, and they’re ranked on the profile’s category, reviews, completeness and distance from the searcher. Your website still plays a part, because Google checks that it matches your profile. Our guide to local SEO for small businesses covers the map results in detail, and local SEO for tradies gives the version for trade businesses.

Google now shows AI-written summaries, called AI Overviews, above many results, and plenty of people ask ChatGPT and similar tools instead of searching. These tools lean on the same foundations, drawing on pages Google has already indexed and favouring clear information about what you do and where. Our guides to ranking in Google AI Overviews and what AEO and GEO mean explain how to show up in them.

What you can control

You can’t control Google’s algorithm, but you can make your site easy to find and trust. Start by making sure nothing blocks Google from your pages, because every other fix depends on it. Then give every page its own clear title and description, and say plainly what you do and where.

After that, make the site quick and secure on a phone, and keep building reviews and mentions from other local sites. The last of those takes months, which is why it pays to start early.

A free SEO audit checks whether Google can index your site and reads your titles and headings, then tests your speed and security, all in about a minute, with the fixes in order.

Google rewards the pages it can find and understand, and both of those are in your hands.

Make the first two steps easy, and the ranking has something to work with.

Want the full picture? See what our free SEO audit checks

Common questions

Can I pay Google to rank higher in the normal results?

No. You can pay for ads, which appear labelled as Sponsored at the top, but you can't pay to rank higher in the free results.

Why did my ranking suddenly drop?

Common causes are a website change that accidentally blocked Google, a new competitor or a Google update. Check your site can still be indexed first, because that's the quickest to fix. A free scan will flag it.

How does Google know where my business is?

From your Google Business Profile, the address and suburbs on your website, your structured data and other sites that mention your business and location.

Run an SEO audit

See your real results and the fixes that matter most.