Skip to content
digitalaudits.com.au

How we score websites and choose providers

Exactly what we test, which tools we use, and how we choose the providers we recommend.

Last reviewed

What we test

AreaToolWhat it checks
SpeedLighthouse, run on our own machines in SydneyLoad times on a phone and a desktop computer with no throttling, plus real-visitor data from Google where it exists.
SEOLighthouse and our own page checksTitles, descriptions, headings, alt text, sitemap, robots.txt and structured data.
MobileLighthouse and our own page checksTap targets, text size, layout on small screens and tap-to-call.
Accessibilityaxe-core, run through LighthouseChecks against WCAG, the international accessibility standard.
SecurityOur own checks and Mozilla HTTP ObservatoryHTTPS, your certificate and its expiry date, secure redirects, mixed content and security headers.
AI searchOur own checks and Claude, with web searchWhether AI crawlers can reach you, how clearly your site says what you do and where, and whether an AI assistant searching the web can identify your business at all.

How scores work

Every area gets a score out of 100. We use the same bands as Google's own tools, and always show a word and a shape alongside the colour. Your overall score is the average of the six areas. Fixes are ordered by how much each one helps, then by how easy it is.

Speed is weighted towards mobile: 70% of that score is the phone result and 30% the desktop one, because most people who find an Australian small business are on a phone. Every other area is measured the same way on both.

Where something couldn't be measured, such as a site that won't show us its robots.txt or a server that drops our security handshake, the report says "Couldn't check" and that check is left out of the score, rather than counted as a pass or a failure.

  • 90 to 100

    Good

    Doing well. Keep an eye on it.

  • 50 to 89

    Needs work

    Worth fixing. Real gains available.

  • 0 to 49

    Poor

    Costing you visitors. Fix these first.

How we measure speed

We run Lighthouse, the open-source engine behind Google's PageSpeed Insights, on our own machines in Sydney. Each scan loads your page twice, once as a phone and once as a desktop computer, with no artificial slowdown on the connection or the processor. The load times in your report are the times we measured.

Your speed score is calculated from those same timings. Every number in the speed section of your report counts: Largest Contentful Paint and Total Blocking Time are worth 25 points each, Cumulative Layout Shift 15, First Contentful Paint, Speed Index and Time to Interactive 10 each, and Time to First Byte 5. Each is marked against the scale Lighthouse uses for fast, unthrottled connections (Google's own bands for Time to First Byte), and your report shows how many points each one cost. PageSpeed Insights tests from outside Australia, imitates a slow 4G phone and scores fewer numbers, so our speed scores won't match Google's. SEO and accessibility scores aren't affected by connection speed, so they line up closely with Google's.

A lab test from a Sydney data centre is a best case. That's why, when Google has enough real Chrome visitors to publish data for your page or site, we show it beside your score as a separate "Real visitors" rating for phones over the last 28 days. Good means it passes Google's Core Web Vitals assessment. It never changes your score, so every site is scored the same way whether or not it has much traffic.

If our Sydney machines are ever unavailable, the scan uses Google PageSpeed Insights instead, and your report says so next to the speed results.

How we choose recommended providers

Providers are pulled from Google's public business listings, or apply to become verified partners. They're only shown if they pass every check below. Nobody can pay to skip them.

  • A Google rating of 4.5 or higher
  • At least 20 Google reviews
  • A website that loads and works
  • For verified partners, an active ABN, checked against the Australian Business Register

Verified partners, who've applied and passed our checks, are shown first. Within each group we rank by rating, review count and distance. Once there's enough traffic, clicks and feedback from people who contacted a provider count too. Sponsored spots are always labelled.

When you request quotes, we pass your request to up to 3 verified partners who handle that work in your area, using the same ranking. Sponsorship makes no difference to who receives your request.

Our "best agencies" pages for each city and service follow the same rules, and we only publish one once at least three providers qualify for it. Ratings are shown as text from Google's public listings, never as our own review scores, and your scan results are never shown to a provider unless you ask for quotes.

What a scan can't tell you

Automated checks are a starting point, not a guarantee. They can miss problems a person would spot, and some results change from one test to the next. Treat your report as a clear, honest guide to where to look first.

See it for yourself

Run a free scan and check our working.